CHAPTER CXXIX.

THE TRIAL OF SWEENEY TODD CONTINUED.

The peculiar circumstances under which Sir Richard Blunt had found out

all the villany of Todd, and overtook him and Mrs. Lovett in the midst

of their iniquities, were well-known to the people assembled in the

court, and some slight manifestations of applause greeted him as he

stood up in the witness-box.

This exhibition of feeling was not noticed by the court, and the

Attorney-General at once began his examination in chief.

"Sir Richard," he said, "will you have the kindness to put into the form

of a narration, what you have to say concerning the charge upon which

the prisoner at the bar is arraigned?"

"I will do so," replied Sir Richard, and then after a moment's pause,

during which you might have heard a pin drop in the court, so intense

was the stillness, the magistrate gave his important testimony against

the now trembling wretch at the bar of that solemn court.

"A considerable time ago," he said, "my attention was drawn to the

circumstance that a number of persons had disappeared, who were

residents about the neighbourhood of Fleet Street, and its vicinity.

Such disappearances were totally and perfectly unaccountable. Not a

trace could be found of very many respectable men, who had left their

houses upon various objects, and never returned to them.

"The most striking peculiarity of this affair was, that the men who

disappeared were for the most part great substantial citizens, who were

far from likely to have yielded to any of those temptations that at

times bring the young and the heedless in this great City into fearful

dangers.

"I saw the Secretary of State upon the subject; and it was agreed that I

was to have a _carte blanche_, as regarded expenses, and that I was to

give nearly the whole of my time and attention to the unravelling of the

mystery. It was then, that after my careful inquiry I found that out of

thirteen disappearances no less than ten had declared their intention to

be to get shaved, or their hair dressed, or to go through some process

which required them to visit a barber. I then, personally, called at all

the barber's shops in the neighbourhood, but never alone. To this fact

of having some one waiting for me in the shop, I no doubt owe my life,

for I have been eight times shaved and dressed by the prisoner at the

bar."

Todd uttered a deep groan, and looked at Sir Richard as though he would

have said--

"Oh, that I had you the ninth time so much at my mercy!"

There was quite a sensation, and a shudder through the court, as Sir

Richard then stated how many times he had run the fearful risk of death

at the hands of such a man as Todd; and then Sir Richard went on with

his narration, which deeply and powerfully interested the judge,

counsel, jury, and spectators.

"I did not find anything suspicious in the shop itself of the prisoner

at the bar; although each of these times that I was within it, I looked

at it narrowly; but I did find that he always made an effort to get the

person who was with me to leave the shop upon some pretext or another,

which, of course, never succeeded; and then without, in the least,

appearing vexed at the failure, he would go on with his shaving in the

coolest possible manner.

"This, however, was only suspicion, and I could take no advantage of it,

unless something else developed itself likewise; but that was not long

in happening. My attention was directed to the peculiar odour in St.

Dunstan's Church, and from the moment that it was so, I in my own mind

connected it with Sweeney Todd, and the disappearances of the persons

who had so unaccountably been lost in the immediate neighbourhood of

Fleet Street. In the midst of all this then, I had a formal application

made to me concerning the disappearance of Mr. Francis Thornhill, who

had been clearly traced to the shop of the prisoner at the bar, and

never seen by any one to leave it.

"From that moment I felt that it was in the prisoner's shop that the

parties disappeared, but the means by which they were murdered remained

a profound mystery, and I felt, that unless these means could be very

distinctly proved, a conviction would be difficult. I instituted a

careful search of the vaults beneath St. Dunstan's Church, and I found a

secret passage communicating with the cellar of the pie shop in Bell

Yard, and afterwards I found a similar passage communicating with the

cellar under the prisoner's shop.

"Upon reaching the latter cellar, the first object that presented itself

to me was, a chair fixed to the roof by its legs. That chair I at once

recognised as identically like the one in the shop, in which I had so

frequently sat, and in a moment the whole truth burst upon me. The plank

upon which the shaving chair rested, turned upon a centre, and could be

so made to turn by a simple contrivance above, so that any unfortunate

person could be let down in a moment, and the vacant or supplementary

chair would come up and take the place of the one that had been above.

"Prosecuting my researches, I found the skeleton of many persons in the

vaults, and much putrid flesh, which fully accounted for the odour in

St. Dunstan's Church. I found likewise that no meat from any butcher or

salesman ever found its way to the pie-shop in Bell Yard. So upon

research actuated by that fact, I found that the supply of flesh was

human, and that was the way the prisoner at the bar got rid of a great

portion of his victims.

"Measures were taken to prevent any more murders, by some persons in my

pay always following any one into the shop; and then, when the evidence

was all ready by the finding and identification of Mr. Francis

Thornhill's leg bone, I took measures to apprehend the prisoner at the

bar. I shall, of course, be happy to answer any questions that may be

asked of me."

The Attorney-General then spoke, saying--

"Have you found out by what means the shaving-chair in the shop of the

prisoner was prevented from falling at the moment any one sat in it?"

"Yes. By a simple piece of mechanism which communicated with the

parlour, he could release the swinging board or keep it firm at his

pleasure. I have had a model of the whole of the apparatus and building,

which will be laid before the jury. It is here in the hands of an

officer."

"Here you is," said Crotchet, coming forward with a large parcel in his

hands, which, upon being taken from its case, was found to be an

accurate representation of Todd's house, with the diabolical

contrivances he had got together for the purpose of murder.

The model was handed to the jury, and excited immense and well deserved

commendation.

"I have no further questions to ask of you, Sir Richard," said the

Attorney-General; "but I am sure the court and jury cannot but feel much

indebted to you for the very lucid manner in which you have given your

evidence."

"One moment, Sir Richard, if you please," said Todd's counsel as the

magistrate was about to leave the witness box. "I will not detain you

for long."

"I am quite at your service, sir," said Sir Richard Blunt.

"How was it then that after you felt convinced of the guilt of the

prisoner at the bar, as you state that you were, although I think upon

very insufficient grounds, that you did not at once arrest him? Does it

not seem very strange that you permitted him for some weeks to go on

just as usual?"

"I did not permit him to go on just as usual. I took every precaution to

prevent him from adding to the list of his offences. It is well known

that a person in my situation must not act upon his own convictions of

the guilt of any party. It was absolutely necessary that I should be

able to bring satisfactory proof before a jury of the guilt of the

prisoner at the bar, and it would have been quite premature to arrest

him until I had that proof."

"And pray, Sir Richard, when did you consider you had that proof?"

"When the surgeon was able to swear to a portion of the remains of Mr.

Francis Thornhill."

"Oh, then I am to understand that you rest the case for the prosecution

upon a bone?"

"I do not prosecute."

"But you took the prisoner into custody, sir; and am I to believe that

you did so solely on account of the finding a bone in some of the vaults

of St. Dunstan's?"

"You can conclude so."

"Oh, I can conclude so? Very well then. Gentleman of the jury, it

appears that the whole case against the prisoner at the bar, my worthy

and exemplary client, rests upon a bone. That will do, Sir Richard; we

will not trouble you any further. Perhaps the court will stop the case,

as it only rests upon a bone."

"Not exactly," said the judge.

The next witness was the surgeon, and his evidence was listened to with

great attention. He said--

"I was in the vaults of St. Dunstan's church, and I looked over a great

quantity of osteological remains. Among those remains I found a male

femur."

"A what, sir?" said Todd's counsel.

"It would be better," said the judge, mildly, "if the witness would be

so good as to give the vulgar names to what he may have to speak of, as

the jury may well be excused for not being in possession of anatomical

and scientific nomenclature."

"I will endeavour to do so," said the surgeon. "I beg to assure the

court, that it was from no feeling of pedantry that I used the

scientific terms; but they are so common professionally, that they are

used without thinking that they are other than the terms in common use."

"That is just the way I view it," said the judge, "and the court had not

the least idea of anything else. Pray go on, sir, with your evidence."

"I found, then, a large quantity of human bones," said the surgeon, "in

the vaults of St. Dunstan's, and among them a male thigh-bone, which I

have with me."

Here he produced from his great-coat pocket the bone he spoke of,

wrapped up in paper, and deliberately untying the string which bound the

paper to it, he handed it to the jury. One of that body, more bold than

the rest, took it, but several of the jurymen shrunk from it.

"Now, sir," said the Attorney-General, "can you upon your oath, without

the slightest reservation, take upon yourself to say whose thigh-bone

this was?"

"I can. It was the thigh-bone of Mr. Francis Thornhill."

"Will you state to the court and jury, the grounds upon which you arrive

at that conclusion?"

"I will, sir. Mr. Thornhill met with an accident of a tedious and

painful nature. The external condyle or projection on the outer end of

the thigh-bone, which makes part of the knee joint, was broken off, and

there was a diagonal fracture about three inches higher up upon the

bone. I had the sole care of the case, and although a cure was effected,

it was not without considerable distortion of the bone, and general

disarrangement of the parts adjacent. From my frequent examination I was

perfectly well acquainted with the case, and I can swear that the bone

in the hands of the jury was the one so broken, and to which I

attended."

"Very well, sir; that is all I wish to trouble you with."

The Attorney-General sat down, but Todd's counsel rose, and said--

"Did you ever have a similar case to that of Mr. Thornhill's under your

treatment?"

"Never a precisely similar one."

"But you have heard of such cases?"

"Certainly."

"They are sufficiently common, not to be positively rare and curious in

the profession?"

"They are not common, but still they do occur sufficiently often to lose

the character of rarity."

"Of course. You have no other means of identifying the bone, but by its

having been fractured in the way you describe?"

"Certainly not."

"Then, it may be the thigh-bone of any one who has suffered a similar

injury."

With this remark, the counsel sat down, and the surgeon was permitted to

retire. The bone was laid upon the counsel's table, and there it reposed

a sad memento of poor Thornhill, and a mute but eloquent piece of

evidence against the prisoner at the bar. Todd, however, did not seem to

be at all moved at the sight of the relict of the murdered victim.

Probably he had for too long a time been intimate with the remains of

mortality, during the frightful trade he had carried on, for such a

circumstance to touch him in any perceptible way.

The next witness called, was another medical man, who merely

corroborated the ship's-surgeon, as to the fact of the bone produced

having been fractured in the way described.